It’s no secret that nailing your brand positioning is one of the most crucial steps in building a successful marketing plan. However, many businesses falter at this point, with their products and services ending up far from the consumer’s mind and in the consumer graveyard.
Here are some of the brand positioning mistakes that many familiar brands have made — and how you can avoid them.
1. Not defining your business challenge properly Defining your problem statement accurately will set you on the right path towards solving it. Many ventures stumble from the start because they fail to precisely articulate the problem they aim to tackle.
“A problem well-stated is a problem half solved.” – Charles Kettering A broad statement like “we want to grow our market share” doesn't provide a clear direction for effectively positioning your brand. Instead, focus on defining specific business objectives and identifying how your brand will deliver unique value to your customers.
To start, thoroughly analyse the current market landscape and articulate the underlying problem and its potential ramifications if left unaddressed. Identify the key stakeholders, their needs, and the desired outcomes. Continuously probe deeper by asking "why is that a problem?" until reaching the core issue. This iterative approach may uncover the root cause, also known as the source problem .
Learning from Ford The cautionary tale of Ford's 1957 launch of the Edsel serves as a stark example. Positioned as the quintessential full-sized car of the future, the Edsel was envisioned as the epitome of suburban luxury. However, Ford's oversight of shifting consumer preferences towards compact cars proved disastrous. Despite gathering data through extensive polling, Ford disregarded crucial insights during the development phase. Consequently, the Edsel's launch was marred by exorbitant pricing, excessive hype, and a glaring ignorance of the target market's genuine needs.
Image from Vintage News Daily 2. Over-positioning your brand On the flip side, over-positioning occurs when brand owners perceive their brand’s value to be higher than it actually is to consumers, leading to inflated pricing strategies that deter potential buyers.
To solve this, brands should adopt a rational approach and conduct comprehensive market research to accurately gauge consumer perceptions of the brand's value. This involves identifying the unique value propositions that differentiate the brand from competitors and justifying its positioning accordingly. Adjusting pricing strategies to reflect the perceived value and offering clear, compelling benefits to consumers can also help counteract over-positioning and enhance the brand's appeal.
Learning from Google A notable case of over-positioning is seen in Google's release of Google Glass. Despite high expectations and an initial buzz surrounding its innovative features, the product failed to gain widespread consumer adoption due to several factors.
Priced at a steep $1,500, it struggled to justify its value proposition beyond basic functions like image capture and internet browsing. Moreover, privacy concerns emerged due to the device's capability to record or photograph without others' knowledge, dampening interest further. Added to this were worries about potential health risks, as the device was worn close to the head. In essence, Google overestimated the appeal and utility of Google Glass, leading to its underwhelming performance in the market despite initial enthusiasm.
Image from The Hacker News 3. Ignoring marketing dynamics In crafting your brand's positioning, overlooking the market dynamics can prove detrimental. It's akin to navigating a landscape without acknowledging other travellers on the journey. By failing to recognise the nuances of the market, you risk missing out on crucial strategic opportunities.
Having a thorough understanding of the broader industry provides valuable insights into gaps and emerging trends. It also enables you to swiftly adapt to the changing market, aligning your business with the industry benchmarks and poised to capitalise on evolving opportunities.
Learning from Blackberry Blackberry's decline exemplifies the inability to pivot in the smartphone market. Once revered as the preferred choice for business professionals, BlackBerry's stronghold stemmed from its robust security features and efficient messaging system. However, as the smartphone landscape evolved, marked by the emergence of touchscreen innovations such as the iPhone and Android devices, BlackBerry faltered in its response.
While competitors embraced touchscreen interfaces and expanded app ecosystems to cater to diverse user needs, BlackBerry remained tethered to its traditional model, neglecting the evolving demands of the market.
Image from Pocket-lint 4. Lack of differentiation This occurs when a brand fails to distinguish itself effectively in the market, leading consumers to perceive it as uninspiring compared to competitors. This perception often arises when consumers believe the brand offers little to no unique value.
To combat this issue, brands should consider rejuvenating their image through various strategies such as introducing innovative product lines, engaging in strategic co-branding initiatives, or leveraging the influence of a brand ambassador. Additionally, it's crucial to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the business to determine whether the issue lies in the offerings themselves or in the perception surrounding the brand.
Learning from Gap For years, Gap Inc., the iconic American clothing retailer, struggled with under-positioning as it faced increasing competition from fast-fashion brands and e-commerce retailers. While its competitors kept up with changing trends through fresh, dynamic collections, Gap’s offerings often appeared stagnant and uninspired. Consumers saw little to distinguish Gap’s products from others, viewing them as bland and lacking the unique appeal that draws in shoppers. This perception of sameness left Gap overshadowed by brands that better understood and responded to the demand for trend-driven fashion. This lag significantly contributed to Gap’s challenges in maintaining market share and appeal.
Image from Freepik 5. Falling Into The “Price War” Trap Embracing a "price war" mentality may seem like a straightforward approach, but it often leads to short-term gains and long-term pitfalls. Competing solely on price can undermine your brand's perceived value and erode profitability over time.
Instead of engaging in a race to the bottom, focus on uncovering a strong competitive advantage that sets your brand apart. Consider whether the inherent value of your products or services justifies their pricing, rather than solely focusing on reducing costs.
Learning from Tesco Tesco, one of the largest supermarket chains in the UK, attempted to regain market share from discount competitors by implementing aggressive price-cutting strategies. However, the deep discounts led to a perception among consumers that Tesco's products were of lower quality, damaging the brand's reputation.
The company also struggled with declining profits as a result of the price war. Tesco eventually shifted its focus to improving the quality of its products and customer service to regain consumer trust and profitability.
Image from Campbell Rigg In essence… Navigating the complexities of brand positioning in the ever-evolving marketplace requires a nuanced understanding of various factors, including market dynamics, consumer preferences, and competitive strategies. Through the exploration of common pitfalls and insightful case studies, it becomes evident that successful brand positioning goes beyond mere pricing strategies or product offerings. It entails a holistic approach that integrates market research, innovation, and a deep understanding of consumer needs.
Whether it's avoiding the pitfalls of under-positioning by revitalising brand image or steering clear of the dangers of engaging in price wars, businesses must remain vigilant and adaptable in their pursuit of sustained success. By embracing strategic differentiation, focusing on value creation, and staying attuned to market trends, brands can carve out their unique position in the market and thrive amidst fierce competition.
Stuck in these branding pitfalls and not sure how to navigate your way out? Don't sweat it! Drop us a line at oh@helloakin.com, and let's work together to overcome your challenges. Whether you're grappling with over-positioning, under-positioning, or finding yourself in the crosshairs of a price war, our team is here to offer tailored solutions and strategic guidance to steer your brand towards success.
Stay connected with us on social media to stay in the loop with our latest updates.
Instagram | LinkedIn | Facebook
